You’ve done your job as a responsible landlord, and you gave the entire rental a new coat of paint.
You even did as this article recommends by painting the walls and trim some variation of beige and white or maybe gray and white. You were being very safe and practical.
You’re hoping the fresh coat of color will attract the “perfect tenant”.
Unfortunately, many tenants don’t mind the neutral color, until they move in. So what do you do when your tenant wants to paint your rental property?
Related: Tip #4: Paint Walls a Neutral Color
Should I Allow My Tenants Paint?
Option 1: Let Them, Unconditionally
If you think this tenant could potentially be a long-term tenant, or if you’re having a really difficult time renting this property, you might want to agree to let them paint.
Most people don’t decide to stay or move based on paint color alone. But if you want to establish a good relationship, possibly setting the stage for a long-term tenancy, work with them.
If you agree to let your tenant paint, make sure you approve the colors first, and find out whether your tenant knows how to paint interior walls.
Beware of Sloppy Results
Although painting is a DIY job everyone thinks they can do, rarely do they get it right. They get paint in areas they shouldn’t, like carpet, ceilings, and trim. Or they don’t wait long enough for the first coat to dry, which leaves ugly, visible brush strokes.
If your tenant isn’t a professional painter, either paint the walls yourself, or hire someone to do it. Because both these options require either time or money from you, it’s not a good idea to choose either one. You should only consider doing so, as mentioned above, if this tenant is signing a multiple-year lease or if the property has been vacant for a while.
Examples of Walls Painted by Tenants
Option 2: Let Them, but with Conditions
If you wish to be a flexible landlord, and your tenant asks whether they can paint, you can let them, but with conditions.
For example, tell your tenant that you will be happy to change the paint color, but that you will do so by hiring a professional painter, which they will need to pay for upfront.
And not only that, you will also charge them to paint the place back to the way you had it.
You have a couple of options on how to accomplish getting the repainting fee at move-out time.
- If your state allows you to charge a nonrefundable fee, charge one, and specify it is a “nonrefundable painting fee.”
- If your state doesn’t allow landlords to charge nonrefundable fees, let your tenant know that you will be taking the cost of repainting the property from their security deposit.
- If there is not enough money in the security deposit to cover any damages that might have occurred in addition to the repainting cost, you will send them a bill.
Your tenant might very well decide at this point that your paint scheme looks pretty good after all.
Option 3: Don’t Let Them – At All
The third option you have when your tenant wants to paint is to “just say no.” Tenants who really want to personalize the space might then ask you about removable wallpaper, also called “renter’s wallpaper.”
This wallpaper is supposed to come off easily without leaving any residue on the walls. But you know how that goes. There’s a great chance that (surprise!) glue residue is left. Even if it’s only left in “one little spot,” according to your tenant, that “one little spot” will still make it necessary for you to repaint the walls.
So make it crystal clear to your tenant that if they damage the walls in any way, including “one little spot,” they need to pay to have it fixed.
Normal Wear and Tear
You can charge your tenant to repaint walls they painted without your permission. But just make sure that you don’t keep part of their security deposit for normal wear and tear, which for walls, would be if they left some minor nicks or scuffs on them. Readying the property for the new tenant is part of your job. You can’t charge an outgoing tenant for your basic upkeep costs.
- Deducting Cleaning and Repair Costs From a Security Deposit
- What Can I Deduct or Withhold From a Security Deposit?
Spend some time researching popular paint colors to determine what most people can live with or will even like. A neutral color, such as Benjamin Moore’s Manchester Tan, for example, is perennially popular.
The more attractive your property looks, the easier it will be to rent, and the less likely it will be for you to have the dilemma of deciding what to do when your tenant wants to paint.