The Pros and Cons of Owning Rental Properties

Written on February 16, 2017 by , updated on December 3, 2019

Key in doorOwning rental properties can be a fantastic way to build wealth and leave a legacy for your children. Let’s review the high-level pros and cons of owning and managing your own rental properties.

While I certainly believe that almost everyone can manage a small portfolio of rental properties if they put their mind to it, I also realize it’s not for everyone. In order for investing in rentals to be “worth it,” the pros have to outweigh the cons, but the weight you give each factor is different for everyone.

Pros of Owning Rentals

  1. Additional recurring revenue
    Rental properties create an independent revenue stream that can cover the operating expenses of the rental or even generate wealth for you and your family.
  2. Tenants paying your mortgage
    The rent you receive will help pay down or pay off your mortgage.
  3. Tax benefits
    You’re able to claim significant income tax deductions because of your rentals.
    Related: Top 15 Tax Deductions for Landlords
  4. Passive side income
    If you have the proper rent collection tools in place, rent can be a passive income stream, allowing you to focus on other things in life. In my opinion, the average person could typically manage between one and five properties while still keeping their full-time job.
  5. Allows you to hold onto the property
    Converting a home to a rental property can prevent the loss of the home due to foreclosure or from being forced to sell it at a loss by generating income. Renting out your home can also allow you to move to another house, city, or country without having to float two mortgages or house payments.
  6. Independent of health
    Building equity through rentals can be independent of age, sickness, or circumstance. It can provide income during requirement or if you are physically unable to work. You may need to hire a property manager though if you are completely unable to participate in the management process.
  7. No shortage of renters 
    The number of renters (your customer) in today’s market is increasing, and they are in every state, city, and town in the U.S.
  8. Low risk
    Even if the economy collapses, people will always need housing.
  9. Self-managing
    I think it is possible for most people to self-manage and self-maintain a rental property. However, even if you’re not “handy” with tools, you can always hire out the repair. You certainly don’t need a property manager to coordinate a plumbing repair. Almost anyone can make a phone call, and the tenants can give the plumber access to do the repair.

Cons of Owning Rentals

  1. More wear and tear
    Maintenance expenses on a rental are typically higher than they are for a homeowner occupied property because people often don’t treat a rental as well as a home they own.
  2. Unqualified renters
    Sometimes you’ll have to deal with people who aren’t worthy of loans or any credit whatsoever. They might lie on an application and waste your time. Roughly 20% (1/5) of my applicants lie about their credit and background check history prior to seeing the screening reports.
  3. Inevitable lawsuits
    If you own a rental, you will eventually get sued, even if you didn’t do anything wrong. Period.
  4. Tougher to sell
    Selling a home while it is occupied by a tenant could lengthen the time it takes to sell and decrease the amount of money a buyer is willing to pay for it.
  5. Additional costs
    Plan on increased expenses for legal fees, legal documents, business formation, CPAs, advisors, vacancy, etc. A rental is a business, which comes with extra business expenses.
  6. Additional stress
    At times, especially during a vacancy, rentals can be extremely stressful. Sometimes, a spouse won’t be so excited about your rental efforts, and it can cause marital stress.

Hiring a Property Manager

If the cons seem too scary, and you shiver in fear of the midnight clogged toilet (which has never happened to me in 11 years of owning rentals), then you could offload the management to a professional property manager. However, it will cost you dearly. In fact, it will likely cost you 17% of your rental income after all fees are calculated in.

The average property management company takes one month’s rent whenever they find a new tenant for you, and then they take 10% of rent every month thereafter — totaling 17%.


Alternatively, you might be able to find a local à la carte property manager, which is a great way to hire out specific services, such as key exchanges and showings, but you will still do some of the work.

The good news is that you can do all the hard parts, like screening and rent collection, through Cozy — and it’s free. Seriously, it’s free. I use Cozy to self-manage my own rentals, and I only hire a property manager when I need someone to be on the ground at a property. So far, it’s worked great and has saved me over $30,000 last year in management expenses.

Get our free newsletter

Join 200,000+ landlords

  • ​Tips to increase income
  • Time-saving techniques
  • ​Powerful tools & resources

8 CommentsLeave a Comment

  • Domenick

    Great article Lucas! I’ve been a land lord for 8 years now. You scared me with the “inevitable lawsuit” part. Fortunately, I’ve avoided this so far. I would add one more downside to be aware of – the inevitable eviction. At some point you will have to evict a non-performing tenant and it will not be pleasant. It will result in months of lost income and extra costs, damages, etc. Always have a reserve!

    • Vladimir

      I agree with Domenick on “inevitable lawsuit”. Knock on the wood this has been avoided so far. Great article and right to the point about marital stress as rentals will put your marriage at risk. To mitigate this risk only one strategy is working- involve your spouse in the decision making. We are trying to understand point of view of each other to come up with a concensus and better understanding of the situation.

  • Steven Freed

    Thanks! Lucas Hall, Great explanation about Pros and Cons of Owning Rental Properties . I really appreciate it.

  • Betsy

    Damn, I wish I could think of soetmhing smart like that!

  • revantaofficersboulevard

    hi mate nice article has been posted about rental property. thanks for posting this blog mate

  • Dana Damato

    After my father in law passed and didn’t leave a will for his 5 family rental property so it had to go to probate. It is coming out of probate and my husband and 3 others will be on the deed of the rental.
    Two of the four siblings are going to take s buy out but my husband may want to stay on the property and own it with his sister. I am skeptical , can you give me some pros and cons?

  • David Norriss

    I like how you mentioned that by buying residential property and then renting it out to people who create a passive income stream while still working a full-time job. People who want to make a lot of side money while still working should look into buying real estate. It can cost them quite a bit of money upfront but they will be recompensated over time. Thank you for teaching me about the benefits of buying and then renting residential properties.

  • Jean

    My husband and I are approx 7 years out from retiring, and are looking to relocate to Florida when we do retire. We are considering purchasing a condo or townhome now, and renting it out, and then when the time comes, and we sell our house that we own, we could either move into the property, or if it is working as a rental we could buy something, with the profits of our current home, to move into and keep renting the property. We have no experience and I don’t even know where to start. Could you advise me?

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 characters available. Be short, sweet and to the point.